I guess there are several ways to determine progress for a football team. Examine the table; Compare recent season results; Transfer activity, etc. But another, and obvious, way is to compare squads. In general, our squad compares favourably with the teams around and below us. But in comparison with the top four teams the story is different.
The United squad has several more highly-skilled players than Spurs and their bench is reasonably strong. We possibly have three or four players who could improve their bench but probably not their starting eleven.
This is even more noticeable when comparing us with Arsenal.
No Spurs player would get a start for City and it’s doubtful they could claim a place on their bench. They have excellent options for a starting eleven and far too much depth.
No Spurs player would be targeted by Chelsea. They have a ridiculously talented squad. They have world class players in every position and like-for-like players waiting to replace them from the bench. Due to rotation requirements (caused by battling on many fronts) Chelsea sometimes have a stronger looking bench than the starting eleven. This somewhat works against them in terms of performance as their first team is not as consistent as most clubs. But that’s a problem managers would love to have.
So …. What is our reality?
We are still young to the WSL and need to be patient. It takes time to build a successful squad. We need to stay ahead of the chasing (although not chasing with too much conviction) pack.
Just like the top four clubs we have a very strong and proud parent club with immense resources. This is the key to success but we will only benefit from those resources if we show how the Women’s team is a viable part of the THFC product. This could be viewed as a chicken-and-egg dilemma. But the fact is that, given the start the top three clubs already have, our development will take some time …. because we will need to improve every playing position before we can compete for trophies.
Just how I see it.
Really good overview Geof ... for me though there is only 1 player who would walk into any of the top 4 and get a regular start and that is Amanda Nilden (but she is not ours yet - its whether she wants to stay)
I generally thought we were buying better last Summer but now having seen nearly a whole season - the new players are OK but not top class (bar Nilden) which makes the fringe players mediocre at best (and why I harp on about it and why we need to do better not keep giving extns to players who are not gonna improve - never - not with us if anyone)... these same fringe players have brought the new players quality down with them esp the like of Ahtinen
My Spurs rating Top 4 club rating Would they sign
Vitikora 6/7 5 No
Bizet 6/7 6 No
Clinton 7/9 7 already with MU
Vinberg 6/7 6 Yes
Grant 7/9 7 Yes
Nilden 8/10 9 Yes
Buhler 5/6 5 No
Shuang 6/7 6 No
Thomas 7/8 7 No
Ahtinen 6/7 6 No
This is the real home truth - we are gtting better but until we start signing top talent and competing at the top 4 table the support will not get any better than 1.5k attendance ... however
"If u build it they will come" but if u take too long WSL support will grow with the other clubs first before us (fact)
This is why all are finding it hard to adapt to RV style of play and tactics and why we go downhill once the mediocre players start to feature more and more.
(Graham Naz Ayanne Neville Spencer Summanen) - trouble is Rv keeps bigging these players up and that worries me more as I reckon we are unlikely to move them on.
Dont get me wrong - we are doing better and more stable now as a squad and club team than last season but we are still way off challenging for top 4/5 - infact Liverpool have done better in 2 seasons that we have done in 6 and that says it all really. They have matched a MU stance on WSL ambition whilst we still lack behind - so when are things gonna change I ask?
It will be an interesting Summer as to what happens with the fringe player and loanees who are still under contract as we really need to start severing the ambilical cords on many of them if we REALLY want WSL ambition.