We do know someone who has been spectacular at getting promotions, but has been in the PL four times and relegated four times, don't we.?
I have long held a theory that managers are either good at working with next to nowt, or good at spending big money. The comment elsewhere about Aldi to Waitrose is absolutely spot on. I don't see any change at all in CW's approach from the end of first lockdown to now. 30 plus games of shyte hoofball, and we are still playing the same formation and style. Thats not suggesting to me that we should give him any more slack at all. He's had 20 games more than any other manager would have had at any other club, and we're still shyte. You can deny it based on four great years, and 'who can we get thats better' but if we're being honest, we know it to be true...
If HRH does think CW is up to it and gives him a chance to get us promoted again, he should do and then if promotion comes he should do the smart thing, fire him and get a foreign manager who knows how to play the PL way.
Two theories I totally agree with and have also mentioned before.
Ability to spend big money always a problem for Aldi buyers.
Sacking the manager who gets you there.
It's harsh but it's realistic.
On a more general basis promoting from within is fraught with problems particularly if you are the one who has promoted/stuck with that person.
You have a vested interest in their success and , often, keep them longer than you would someone from outside, when you know that you need to do the right thing.
It can also be counter productive for them as they know deep down that they can't hack it but don't want to quit and let you down.
Once promoted beyond their ability level there is no fall back position, except for losing face and going back into the ranks, or leaving.
As I said in another post how does the prince get assurances from CW that he has learned from his mistakes? If he challenges him on a football basis, his methods, his tactics, his style, his results, he's seen as interfering.
If he doesn't he shows he hasn't learned from the expeience either and is putting faith in hope over experience.
Keeping CW on will mean setting him some very specific timed tagets for him to achieve before the prince takes action.How long does he 'trust in Wilder'???