The Super John McGinn Thread
- Thread starter villahibs
- Start date
Melon Donkey
I am a little bit perplexed
SJM trouble maker ?.
Nah. No chance. Can't use that as an excuse to get rid.
If anyone was a trouble maker it was newboy Beale who promptly left at the first chance, despite being the alleged brains behind the SG operation.
4 years of SJM and not a whiff of an issue. If there was a problem between him and Beale then there is only one place to look.
Nah. No chance. Can't use that as an excuse to get rid.
If anyone was a trouble maker it was newboy Beale who promptly left at the first chance, despite being the alleged brains behind the SG operation.
4 years of SJM and not a whiff of an issue. If there was a problem between him and Beale then there is only one place to look.
AstonBurrito
Vital Champions League
I don't believe SJM is a trouble maker. Though this story was written in Football Insider so make of it what you will.
I just meant that we were supposedly in for Bentancur & Bissouma so that would be our 'alternative reality' midfield
JuanPabloAngel
Alert Team
sirdennis
Alert Team
Thank you JPA.
Nowhere near as bad as some make out on here , and a lot of the good stuff he does gets overlooked.
DeanoVilla
One Bloody Number
Said it all along, Mcginn is the least of our problems.
That's quite a stat isn't it. Proper all round midfielder.
That's quite a stat isn't it. Proper all round midfielder.
Melon Donkey
I am a little bit perplexed
Everyone had a price as we know. And if we get offered stupid money on a 3 million pound signing then we will probably take it.
However, I 100 % think SG rates him, wants him and is not looking to move him on at all. Cannot envisage him leaving this summer one bit.
However, I 100 % think SG rates him, wants him and is not looking to move him on at all. Cannot envisage him leaving this summer one bit.
Silhillvilla
Vital Football Legend
He's one of our best players (despite the passing issues) , we should not be selling our best players . I would not be upset if he got the armband. Proper grafter and strong.
Platypus
Vital Football Hero
This sounds like two random stats picked out to make someone sound exceptional who really isn't. Honestly, trusting your own eyes, is John McGinn one of the best midfielders in his position in Europe? No. No he isn't. He's fine but this random compound stat doesn't account for his poor short passing and poor decision making in possession, which we can understand by using our own eyes.
Silhillvilla
Vital Football Legend
My eyes tell me he's still one of our most important players as things stand.
The French Connection
Vital Squad Member
I don’t think he’s a bad player by any means, but I can’t remember him having that many great games last season. Maybe he’s just not being deployed in a way that would get the best out of him. Possibly.
My feeling with him and Luiz is that we could do with better if we are to progress and that things need freshening up. Gallagher and Sangare for example would I think do that, and with the proceeds of the sales, I don’t think we would be that much out of pocket.
My feeling with him and Luiz is that we could do with better if we are to progress and that things need freshening up. Gallagher and Sangare for example would I think do that, and with the proceeds of the sales, I don’t think we would be that much out of pocket.
AstonBurrito
Vital Champions League
It's true he's not the biggest issue that we have at Villa Park, but he's such an inconsistent player, in a team that performed inconsistently.
Wicked Messenger
Vital 1st Team Regular
Great presence at club and with 5 subs a definite stayer for me.
DeanoVilla
One Bloody Number
Can't you say the same about all of the others though? Maybe Matt Cash excluded, who else was consistent?
