My thoughts in no particular order:
Jack doesn’t know what player he wants to be, for me he needs to model his game on someone successful and stick with it. He wants to be everyone, my advice to him is that he’ll ultimately be remembered for the assists and goals he creates, not the amount of touches he has in a game. Bruno Fernandez is a player I like that jack could be, it’s different circumstances but it’s the same role.
He needs to learn, and be coached, about tempo - when to play it forwards quickly and when to hold onto it. Too often, it’s the latter when it should be the former. If we’re 3-0 up, take as many touches as you want and slow it down. Too many half opportunities are lost because jack wants to make a guaranteed pass but there’s nothing wrong with a quick ball over the top to a winger.
Positionally, he doesn’t stick to his role. I reckon there must be some frustration within the ranks. Too often today he’s dropping to pick the ball up off Mings in arms distance of Luiz and Marv. None of them have any understanding, if Luiz was being pulled away I would get it.
As a captain, he doesn’t have leadership qualities to take control when things go badly. Against Chelsea, we needed to sit tight for ten yet we conceded immediately after goal number 1. Justice before half time today, him and Hourihane messed up an opportunity to get it in the box from a free kick. I don’t see a smart leader with stereotypical captain attributes, I see a player who leads by example which is great when’s things are going well.
Jack is probably the most talented player we have ever had in the top flight, in one of the worst ever premier league sides we’ve had. He’s over compensating but he’s also proving to be a massive problem with his lack of awareness. I’m not jack bashing before anyone pulls me up on it. It’s constructive criticism for jack to improve when he moves on to better things, and also for us to make him more productive in these final few games.