Divine_islet
Vital 1st Team Regular
The argument I suppose is that Luiz is better on the ball, but since Christmas he's not doing anything with it. Can't remember the last time I said "brilliant pass by Dougie." Marv is simple in possession, but much more effective off the ball - covers more ground, wins tackles more, tracks runners better and only gives away fouls when absolutely necessary. Dougie is good for 2/3 stupid fouls per match.
Not a coincidence that Marv was in the role when we've had our "better" performances since Christmas.....
I am not seeing what others are seeing as far as Luiz' attacking ability goes. It makes sense to start Luiz if he was either a better DM than Marv or if they were both equally good at it but Luiz was effective when we attack. But the fact is he isnt. Hence for me Marv starts always.