Whilst Reina should be dropped. Nyland is genuinely one of the worst keepers I've seen play for us, heroics against Leicester aside he was nothing short of an unmitigated disaster whenever he played last season and he was pathetic this season against Man City, conceding a number of soft goals.
You could see the way it was going to go after Hourihane's air shot.
Play like this and not only won't we win another game but we'll lose the lot.
Douglas Luiz, one fucking tackle all game.
Our full backs, successful pass percentages of 47 and 51.
Absolute crap statistics.
Do we even need statistics Fulford, I feel like those only come into play when you've a dodgy argument or an argument which isn't commonly accepted.
I think its pretty commonly accepted we're not competitive anymore. We were at times during our first 12-16 games but the last 10 in particular have been dreadful.
We don't even need to cherry pick examples the data set is very broad. Even games we won like Watford we were dreadful for 60 odd minutes. Burnley was our one decent performance, a red herring among the pack.
One tackle in 90 mins is pathetic.
We played very well against Spurs. Why are people expecting us to dominate the league? We finished 5th in the play offs and have a squad worth less than Arsenal's front three.Do we even need statistics Fulford, I feel like those only come into play when you've a dodgy argument or an argument which isn't commonly accepted.
I think its pretty commonly accepted we're not competitive anymore. We were at times during our first 12-16 games but the last 10 in particular have been dreadful.
We don't even need to cherry pick examples the data set is very broad. Even games we won like Watford we were dreadful for 60 odd minutes. Burnley was our one decent performance, a red herring among the pack.
We played very well against Spurs. Why are people expecting us to dominate the league? We finished 5th in the play offs and have a squad worth less than Arsenal's front three.
One of the very few games we haven't scored under Smith. Another game full of individual errors.We should be expecting to dominate as according to your assessment of our football under Smith "We play better football under Dean than I have seen us play since the 90s. We are scoring goals, we try and play with possession, we overload the opposition half and box, we put passes together, we are dynamic. "
Where was all of that yesterday?
One of the very few games we haven't scored under Smith. Another game full of individual errors.
I'm not sure how blaming individual errors is some type of exoneration for the coaching/manager. If players are making individual errors that lead to goals (apparently we lead the league) then that is down to the fact that the shape and (lack of) organization isn't right. Players make mistakes all the time. The whole idea of having a defined defensive shape is to ensure that those moments aren't punished with goals. It's the simple concept of pressure/cover defensively. If the player pressing the ball makes a mistake, then there is a covering player in the right place to help. A defender getting beaten in a 1v1 situation is normal. That defender not having a covering player is the problem under this manager.One of the very few games we haven't scored under Smith. Another game full of individual errors.
Exactly this. Said to Sir Dennis on the way back that even if our game in hand was against Norwich, no way would I fancy us. It's against Europe-chasing Sheffield United and even though it's at home, I can't see us getting anything.I just can't imagine any Villa fan came out of that game thinking oh well we've still got a game in hand
i would argue this team, is worse than the team we had last year, I dont see how Guilbert is any better than the Scottish cafu or Engels is any better than Chester, Im not saying the latter players should be still in the team but they are championship at best! late in the second half I witnessed A Leicester Player on the Floor but still won the ball against 1st Davis,2nd Luiz & then El Ghazi, they all stuck there Toe in, for Fear of getting Hurt - I couldn't believe it, but it sums Up This Team Under Smith.
I'd also take Glen Whelan over Luiz or Nakamba... He'd probably have about six red cards by now with most of them for nutting his own teammates....i would argue this team, is worse than the team we had last year, I dont see how Guilbert is any better than the Scottish cafu or Engels is any better than Chester, Im not saying the latter players should be still in the team but they are championship at best! late in the second half I witnessed A Leicester Player on the Floor but still won the ball against 1st Davis,2nd Luiz & then El Ghazi, they all stuck there Toe in, for Fear of getting Hurt - I couldn't believe it, but it sums Up This Team Under Smith.