Weweregoodonce
Vital Reserves Team
Semedo and Silva and Mir.Lets look at our "XI" and see who is shit
Muric
Jenkinson/Cash
Worrall
Dawson
Semedo
Watson
Sow/Silva
Lolley
Ameobi/Adomah
Grabben/Mir
How many are "shit"
Semedo and Silva and Mir.Lets look at our "XI" and see who is shit
Muric
Jenkinson/Cash
Worrall
Dawson
Semedo
Watson
Sow/Silva
Lolley
Ameobi/Adomah
Grabben/Mir
How many are "shit"
I’ve not heard him say we’ve been lucky but if he has his definition could be completely different to yours.
You say we should have been a hatful down but on what basis?
Keepers are there to make saves and defenders are there to make last ditch tackles.
We can only deal in facts and the facts are neither Leeds or Charlton who are the form teams right now could beat us absolutely nothing to do with anything other than reality.
Hodgy said they were relegation fodder didn't he? I don't need to ask actually, I know he did. Of course football is subjective and what Hodgy did say, I know the moaners like to glean bits and bobs, was that the forward line was awful and that getting it forward through the middle was good. For our fans, who didn't watch the games but instead chose the comfort of their sofas with the wireless, we were not terrible against WBA. The keeper was and we sat a little too deep, but we wasn't "shit". Leeds first half we were completely swarmed and attack wise we was "shit" but defensively we looked great. Second half we were good. Charlton a very similar story and Brum we were excellent to a man.
Defensively, this season we look superb. Lets not give Lamouchi any credit for that though.
Not impressed with Mir at all.
Now change your question from shit to "potential promotion winners" and see what the answer is
Charlton we were awful for 45, Dawson and Worrall apart.
Birmingham fans think they're relegation fodder and were extremely lucky in previous games.
No, because the general consensus is shit. I don't see anyone talking up promotion but plenty saying it's shit. So Besides Mir, what are they? Bog standard?
Luck looks like how many points?
A football fans perspective is hilarious. I blame EA Sports.
I watched the Chelsea V Liverpool game and wasn't impressed at all. They are both shit.
Nice one.
In which case you would be comparing to the exception, not the rule. Last year's set of average players were able to very comfortably beat Sheffield United.Stand them side by side to Sheffield UTD
Charlton who haven't lost in the league yet and beat and outplayed "championship" Blackburn and Stoke?
I'm not saying a good start isn't desirable.
It is clear to everyone (surely) that we aren't likely to be promoted this year, and probably not even fighting for it.
I'm just saying that the start we have had, and particularly the performances are entirely in keeping with what is typical for forest in any season, whether it's one where we do well or not.
Last time we were promoted we won none of the first four.
In which case you would be comparing to the exception, not the rule. Last year's set of average players were able to very comfortably beat Sheffield United.
In reality you need to stand the current lot side by side with Fulham and Leeds who are the actual standard in this division
Lets look at our "XI" and see who is shit
Muric
Jenkinson/Cash
Worrall
Dawson
Semedo
Watson
Sow/Silva
Lolley
Ameobi/Adomah
Grabben/Mir
How many are "shit"
Forest fans do need a sense of perspective CP. I know you are not over enamoured by recruitment but this guy is your type of manager isn't he? I am sure you can see green shoots as you do know football a little more than most on here. (even though you haven't played at a decent level lol)
I've never said we are "shit", so hope you're not quoting me? I've just commented on our performances so far. But as you've asked:
Muric - jury still out.
Jenkinson/Cash - very good/promising
Worrall - excellent
Dawson - excellent
Semedo - poor
Watson - poor
Sow/Silva - not seen enough/poor
Lolley - excellent
Ameobi/Adomah - ok/good
Grabben/Mir - excellent/poor
Standard for promotion, which is what I was talking about. We could alternatively talk pedantry while you start an argument again if you prefer?Lest than 10% are the actual standard?
No wonder education is shot.
I am absolutely not singling out you Hardy.
I dont agree with your ratings, I think Semedo, bar the Charlton game has looked very good. Jury out also in respect of Silva and Sow, but on the whole over 50% of your ratings are good or excellent. Not a bad start after a few games?
I am absolutely not singling out you Hardy.
I dont agree with your ratings, I think Semedo, bar the Charlton game has looked very good. Jury out also in respect of Silva and Sow, but on the whole over 50% of your ratings are good or excellent. Not a bad start after a few games?