Surely not. Pep is the best coach on the planet, a veritable football god! That kind of man, with the resources to boot, cannot possibly have got it wrong.
That he has got egg on his face fills me with more amusement than his team getting beaten. Maybe he'll get it right next time around after another supermarket sweep of the world's best paid players. Failing that he might do better at PSG in a year or so.
He has certainly consistently bought the wrong defenders. When you think about it he didn't sign their most influential attacking players either namely De Bruyne, Aguero, Sterling or David Silva.
He is a football purist and will not change his playing style no matter what. He believes retaining and quickly recovering possession when the ball is lost is king - i.e. you can't lose if you keep the ball. When it works it is great but if the opposition are very well organised and have pace, height and athleticism then he has nowhere else to go.
Another problem he sometimes encounters is he constantly plays a ridiculously high line with complete disregard to the pace and/or quality of the opposition which in combination with some distinctly average defenders is not a great idea. As Brian Clough observed - it only takes a second to score a goal.
You can see it coming a mile off against some opposition; home v Wolves and Traore panned out exactly as I predicted.
It's one of the things I will watch with interest with MAPP. I love and fully support what he is implementing with us but I do hope he is a little more flexible than Guardiola. I have commented previously how effective we were going forward in the home league game v Ipswich because we mixed it up so well and their defenders didn't know at any point in that game what was coming next and as a result were never settled.