I know football supporters can be a parochial bunch but it’s worth pointing out a few facts about the Scally era to date.
He's been in charge for 27 seasons. This is his 28th. We have spent 5 seasons in tier 4, 17 seasons in tier 3 and 5 seasons in tier 2. We have finished as high as 11th in tier 2 and the lowest we’ve finished is 8th in tier 4. In that time we have appeared at the old Wembley twice and the new Wembley once. We have been promoted 4 times and relegated 4 times. We have reached the quarter finals of the FA Cup. The ground is now a serviceable all seater stadium, something that could never have been claimed for the old ground.
In that time we have never been in serious financial difficulty. We have not been in administration since Scally took us out of administration. We have never had a winding up petition from HMRC. Despite all the talk about the club being a poor employer I am only aware of one successful claim against the club and that was the McCammon case where the club lost on a procedural issue.
There are clubs that have had a history of insolvency events.
Aldershot 1990, 1992
Bournemouth 1997, 2008
Bradford City 2002, 2004
Crawley Town 1999, 2006
Darlington, 1997, 2003, 2009
Exeter City 1994, 2003
Halifax Town 1987, 1999, 2002, 2004
Luton Town 1999, 2003, 2007
Rotherham Utd 1987, 2006, 2008
Scarborough 1999, 2003
Swanse City 1985, 2003
Swindon Town 2000, 2003
Wolves 1982, 1986
This was just up to 2010 (the date of the report I took this info from). Since then there have been the well recorded issues at Derby, Bury, Bolton, Swindon (again) and Southend to name but a few.
Over the same period many well known clubs and those of an equal or higher stature than the Gills have spent lengthy periods out of the League including Notts County, Wrexham, Oxford United, Luton Town, Torquay United, York City, Colchester, Tranmere, Carlisle and now Southend. There are probably more. Stockport, York and Torquay have been down as far as the 6th tier of the pyramid.
In the wider football community it’s not a surprise that Scally is not so badly thought of as by a minority of our support base. Given our historically low fan base, I think his record has been more than decent.