Rate the Ref: Home to Reading 16.12.2023

[sedgleyimp]

Robert Madley was the man in the middle today.
How do you think he did
Comments and votes out of 10 please

 

[bonsonshead]

On top of most things, could have just warned Jenson as it was a bit early to be time wasting 8.

 

[nrimp]

On top of most things, could have just warned Jenson as it was a bit early to be time wasting 8.

He warned him a couple of times before the booking.

 

[impsimps]

8, made it look easy, no dramas, warned Jensen for time wasting before booking him, think their guy conned him when booking Hamilton though

 

[Norfolk Imp]

Considering he disallowed a couple of their goals which I thought looked legitimate initially, he deserves an 8 at least.

 

[DEEPING IMP]

Thought he was very good. 9

 

[plumbob]

From several minutes after Reading kindly scored for us it looked inevitable that Jensen would be booked. The ref probably gave him a little too much slack on it.
Thought perhaps he was a little whistle happy at times. No idea about the 2 ruled out goals, but thankful for them.
8

 

[johnolbe]

9. As good as he always is. Refs with authority and got just about all decisions spot on

 

[Eweimps]

8.5/10

 

[robbochops]

9. Simply a class above most refs in this league.

 

[Chartist]

He is always good. A shame his past damaged his career, but it's our gain.

 

[clanford]

Thought he was an okay ref. Up with most things. Very happy with the two disallowed goals and lenient on Duffy who I thought was going to get a straight red.

 

[johnolbe]

He is always good. A shame his past damaged his career, but it's our gain.

It was more a case of political correctness gone made and the PGMOL being spineless and towing the line and throwing all common sense out the window.

 

[kettrin imp]

7.5. Consistent throughout the game.

 

[sedgleyimp]

Robert Madley maintains his usual high standards with an average of 8.3 for this one