Rate The Players v Carlisle United | Vital Football

Rate The Players v Carlisle United

Scotimp

Scotimp

Vital Football Legend
Just back... attritional... nervy... challenging... but enough of my drive home. What about the game?

6.0 is the par score etc.

Deadline is 5pm on Thursday.

Wright
Sorensen
Mitchell
O'Connor
Roughan
Hackett
Erhahon
Bishop
Moylan
House
Taylor

Makama
..................
 
Wright 8
Sorensen 7
Mitchell 7
O'Connor 7
Roughan 7
Hackett 5.5
Erhahon 8.5
Bishop 8
Moylan 5.5
House 7.5 (hard to rate as he had a goal and assist but I actually don't think his overall game was great today)
Taylor 7.5 (see Ben House)

Makama 7
 
Wright 8
To come in at such a late stage and play like he did was a credit to him considering how little game time he has had. Made a couple of good saves and faultless handling.

Sorensen 7
Hasn't been as prominent going forward in the last couple of games but did ok.

Mitchell 7
Another impressive defensive performance.

O'conner 7.5
Defended bravely and put his head in where it hurts. Put a great header back across the six yard box from a corner that should of been buried in the first half.

Roughan 7
Or Ruffen is how he's always referred to by the opposition commentators (who incidently were very good). Stuck to his task well.

Hackett 5.5
Under par performance from him.
Saw a fair bit of the ball but failed to produce much today.

Erhahon 8.5
You know what you have missed when he's been out the side and comes back in. Breaks play up and uses the ball well.

Bishop 8
Picks up the ball and can run at the opposition. Draws an awful lot of fouls and finished one of those off in style today.

Moylan 5
Been underpar since his sensational game at Barnsley. Had a bit of a cameo at the end but not really involved or influencing the game today expected him to be substituted.

House 6.5
Made one and scored one
Was in the hole just behind Taylor but not his usual bag of energy today.

Taylor 7
We weren't fluent today in respect of creating chance after chance but the comparison chance they had to us was that they hit the post but Taylor put his in the back of the net. Intelligent header as well for the first goal where you would of seen many players trying to score from that.

Makama 7
Draper 7
 
Last edited:
clanfordimp said:
Wright 8
To come in at such a late stage and play like he did was a credit to him considering how little game time he has had. Made a couple of good saves and faultless handling.

Sorensen 7
Hasn't been as prominent going forward in the last couple of games but did ok.

Mitchell 7
Another impressive defensive performance.

O'conner 7.5
Defended bravely and put his head in where it hurts. Put a great header back across the six yard box from a corner that should of been buried in the first half.

Roughan 7
Or Ruffen is how he's always referred to by the opposition commentators (who incidently were very good). Stuck to his task well.

Hackett 5.5
Under par performance from him.
Saw a fair bit of the ball but failed to produce much today.

Erhahon 8.5
You know what you have missed when he's been out the side and comes back in. Breaks play up and uses the ball well.

Bishop 8
Picks up the ball and can run at the opposition. Draws an awful lot of fouls and finished one of those off in style today.

Moylan 5
Been underpar since his sensational game at Barnsley. Had a bit of a cameo at the end but not really involved or influencing the game today expected him to be substituted.

House 6.5
Made one and scored one
Was in the hole just behind Taylor but not his usual bag of energy today.

Makama 7
Draper 7
Click to expand...
Taylor comments missing Totally agree with the rest
 
libertine said:
Wright 8
Sorensen 7
Mitchell 7
O'Connor 7
Roughan 7
Hackett 5.5
Erhahon 8.5
Bishop 8
Moylan 5.5
House 7.5 (hard to rate as he had a goal and assist but I actually don't think his overall game was great today)
Taylor 7.5 (see Ben House)

Makama 7
Click to expand...
Totally agree
 
Wright - 8
Sorensen - 6
Mitchell - 7
O’Connor - 8
Roughan - 7.5
Hackett - 6.5
Bishop - 8
Erhahon - 7.5
Moylan - 6
Taylor - 6.5
House - 7.5

Makama - 7.5
Draper - 7
 
Live via iFollow

Wright 7.5
Sorensen 7
Mitchell 6.5
O'Connor 7.5
Roughan 7
Hackett 5
Erhahon 8
Bishop 7.5
Moylan 6
House 7.5
Taylor 7.5

Makama 7
 
Wright - 8
Sorensen - 7
Mitchell - 7
O’Connor - 8
Roughan - 7
Hackett - 6
Bishop - 9 MotM :clap:
Erhahon - 8.5
Moylan - 6
Taylor - 7
House - 7

Makama - 6.5
 
Attended game

Wright 8 - Superb considering he had to come in following Jensen's injury
Sorensen 6.5
Mitchell 6.5
O'Connor 7.5
Roughan 7
Hackett 6
Erhahon 8
Bishop 7.5
Moylan 6
House 7.5
Taylor 7

Makama 7
 
Last edited:
Wright - 8.5
Sorensen - 7
Mitchell - 8
O’Connor - 8
Roughan - 7
Hackett - 5
Bishop - 8.5
Erhahon - 8
Moylan - 6
Taylor - 7
House - 6.5
Makama - 6.5
 
Via ifollow
Wright 8 - showed his qualities and patience, really stepped up when called upon at short notice.
Sorensen 6.5 - not at his recent standards but an assist-assist for 1st goal.
Mitchell 7 - solid
O'Connor 7.5 - solid; unlucky to hit post
Roughan 7.5 - some tough tackling, gets forward well, developing into a classy centre back.
Hackett 6.5 - as Lasse, tried but below recent standards.
Erhahon 8.5 - we'll forgive the hair. Controlled the pitch and his temper, maintain both and we're in with a chance.
Bishop 8.5 - superb, despite some quiet spells. Capped with a Grant-esque free kick which he'd won. Hit a spell of fitness and form in his best position and crucial to the next few weeks.
Moylan 6.5 - never really in the game, though some occasional moments of classy touches. We need hime to hit the peaks of Barnsley and Cambridge again.
House 8- scored, fine break and pass for 2nd, covered every blade of grass. close to his best.
Taylor 7.5 - great finish for his goal, thought he'd over-elaborated with the knock down for the opener but what do I know? Worked hard betweentimes.

Makama 8- the growth in confidence and effectiveness continues.
Shout out for the other subs - Draper, Duffy, Jacko, TJ - who all contributed to the terrific game managament of the last 15 minutes. Draper and Makama in particular delivered mature and intelligent control which belied their years and which Rheady would have been proud of.
 
Not normally one to join in on player ratings, but think few others have been very harsh on House so decided to get involved!

Wright - 8
Sorensen - 7
Mitchell - 7.5
O’Connor - 8
Roughan - 8 - his best Imps form has coincided with this run, excellent again.
Hackett - 6
Bishop - 9 - superb.
Erhahon - 8.5
Moylan - 6.5
Taylor - 8 - excellent goal and excellent assist, can’t be less than an 8!?
House - 8.5 - goal, assist and covered every blade of glass. Can’t believe some of the ratings for House, guess it shows the high standards people now have of him!?

Makama - 7
 
Wright - 7.5
Sorensen - 6.5
Mitchell - 7
O'Connor - 8
Roughan - 7
Hackett - 5.5
Erhahon - 7.5
Bishop - 7
Moylan - 6.5
House - 7.5
Taylor - 7

Makama - 7
 
Gaz_Imp said:
Not normally one to join in on player ratings, but think few others have been very harsh on House so decided to get involved!

Wright - 8
Sorensen - 7
Mitchell - 7.5
O’Connor - 8
Roughan - 8 - his best Imps form has coincided with this run, excellent again.
Hackett - 6
Bishop - 9 - superb.
Erhahon - 8.5
Moylan - 6.5
Taylor - 8 - excellent goal and excellent assist, can’t be less than an 8!?
House - 8.5 - goal, assist and covered every blade of glass. Can’t believe some of the ratings for House, guess it shows the high standards people now have of him!?

Makama - 7
Click to expand...
Please keep joining in!
 
Wright - 8 Really good performance on the day.
Sorensen - 7 Lovely cross lead to first goal, worked hard.
Mitchell - 7.5 Solid as per usual
O’Connor - 8 Another captain’s performance, deserved a goal.
Roughan - 7.5 Worked his socks off.
Hackett - 6 Less combative than of recent.
Bishop - 8.5 When he’s good he’s very, very good. Quality free kick.
Erhahon - 8 Commanded the midfield.
Moylan - 6.5 Worked hard but less effective than others in midfield.
Taylor - 7.5 Clinical finishing, unselfish assist.
House - 7.5 They bounced off him, well taken goal

Makama - 7 Put himself about.
Word for all the subs who played their part in the last 15 mins.
 
Wright. 8.
Must have been nervous with the late call up but didn’t show it. Cool and calm and some good saves plus decent distribution.

Sorensen. 6
Great cross for the first goal but wasteful with other opportunities in the first half hour. Defended ok.

Mitchell 6.5
OConnor 6.5
Roughan 6.5
All solid except for the 20 minutes after half time when we looked a bit ragged especially through the middle. Introduction of Jacko steadied the situation and we didn’t give them any openings in the 20 minutes he played. Was that Jacko organising and plugging the gaps and is it time for him to start or was it to down to reverting to a flat back 5 MK style to see the game out.

Hackett 5.5
Not happening for him at the minute, had a great opportunity to play Taylor through but dallied and Taylor ran offside. Summed up his performance overall I.e not quite on it over the 2 weekend games

Erhahon. 8.
Imposed himself and commanded his patch apart from the early part of the second half when they ran beyond him a few times

Bishop 8.5.
Most influential player on the pitch, got us up the pitch with strong running and sublime postage stamp free kick to seal the deal. MoM performance, they could only stop him by numerous fouls.

Moylan 6
Bypassed especially first half but grew into the second half and enjoyed a good last 20 minutes to steady the ship when we looked to be rocking.

House 7.5
Put a real shift in, played a part in the build up and scored the first goal and his burst forward and pass created Taylor’s goal.

Taylor 7.5.
Quality head back for the assist for the House goal and brilliant curling effort to score. Hassled and harried and constant shithousery to annoy their defence and their fans

Makama. 6.5. Continued his fighting spirit of late. Did what was needed
 
Wright - 7
Sorensen - 6.5
Mitchell - 6
O'Connor - 7.5
Roughan - 7.5
Hackett - 6
Erhahon - 7.5
Bishop - 8
Moylan - 6
House - 7
Taylor - 7

Makama - 6.5
 
Wright 7.5 Secure and good distribution
Sorensen 7 still tireless
Mitchell 7 Rock solid
O'Connor 7.5 Made of granite
Roughan 7 Radar better today than Friday
Hackett 5.5 below par today. Half hearted contests for the ball in defence, could have been costly. In fairness everybody can have an off day.
Erhahon 8 Rolls Royce, just the attitude sometimes has me thinking, it's easy for referees to book him.
Bishop 9 Can't believe Teddy's only 27, get him on a new contract
Moylan 6 Better second half
House 7.5 Ran his bliming socks off!!
Taylor 8 I don't really care too much for his contributions apart from the final third of the pitch... he's a goal machine!

Makama 7 Good strength to help see the game out
 
You must log in or register to reply here.