Enjoying this thread, thanks JF but have decided to take a slightly different approach in order to make an impossible task a little easier and shine a light on some history :69: Going to choose by position, starting with keepers;
Billy George: £50 from the Army :10: 1897-1911 396 games, 3 titles, 1 FA Cup, 3 England caps. When we'd finished with him we sold him to the Blues. Cruel :21:
"One of the greatest – if not the greatest – goalkeeper in the history of the club. For many seasons was at the top of his form, after a superb opening display against WBA. Quick on his feet, splendid reach, full of resource, punches the ball with great power, fields well, and a grand kick. A rare good man on a side, and an ornament to the game" — The Villa News and Record, 1 September 1906
Con Martin: 1948- 1956, 194 games. Played for both Ireland and Northern Ireland, as well as Gaelic football! Also played outfield. Got to be in for that reason alone!
"Martin, nicknamed Mr. Versatility,[1] played in nearly every position during his soccer career. Although he played mainly as a centre-half, the ball-handling skills he developed playing Gaelic football also made him a very useful goalkeeper. He actually made his international debut with the FAI XI as a goalkeeper and despite turning down the chance to sign for Manchester United as a goalkeeper, he later played nearly a whole season in goal for Aston Villa".
Nigel Sims: 1956-1964, 264 games.
"He was on the winning side in the 1957 FA Cup Final, in which Villa beat Manchester United 2–1, followed three years later by a Second Division winners' medal. In 1961, he helped Villa lift the inaugural League Cup. He played representative matches for the Football League, and in 1958, was the first winner of Aston Villa supporters' 'Terrace Trophy".
Jimmy Rimmer: 1977 -1983, 229 appearances.
Div 1 winner, 2 (yes 2) European Cup winners medals but only played 9 mins! After being understudy to Stepney for Man Utd in 1968, he was man enough to admit his injury prevented him from doing his best, without that honesty, we may never have become European Champions. Solid and reliable, having been an understudy at United and replaced by Pat Jennings after a couple of seasons at Arsenal.
Nigel Spink 1977-1996, 361 appearances. European Cup 1982, European Super Cup 1983, League Cup 1994. 1 England cap. Spink and Rimmer are two of the four England goalkeepers with the shortest international career (45 minutes).
What can you say! To make your second appearance (after 5 years of waiting) in the European Cup final and be calm and assured says a lot about the man. Mr reliable for the next 14 years.
Special mention for Jimmy Cumbes, John Burridge and Mark Bosnich for some golden moments.