What are we going to get dinged with?

[TMFwanstead]

i dont want an appeal if its 6 or less

Why not? Even if it’s a small amount like 2 points I would consider depending on what the judgement report says. We had had some conjecture about what happened with the Johnson sale but until we know for sure we can’t really speculate on an appeal

 

[Pope John XXIII]

Why? I'd appeal if its 1 point, just to put the 'See you next Tuesdays' through the ringer and spend more cash

Because then you end the season not knowing if they are going to increase it a few days later and relegate you.

When you appeal it can go up as well as down.

If we get relegated there is absolutely zero chance of them changing it and relegating someone else.

Even now, the whole thing makes a mockery of the integrity of the competition, giving us a points deduction with just 9 games to go.

 

[paz1967]

Why not? Even if it’s a small amount like 2 points I would consider depending on what the judgement report says. We had had some conjecture about what happened with the Johnson sale but until we know for sure we can’t really speculate on an appeal

cos that takes it probably past the season end

 

[finbar70]

Because then you end the season not knowing if they are going to increase it a few days later and relegate you.

When you appeal it can go up as well as down.

If we get relegated there is absolutely zero chance of them changing it and relegating someone else.

Even now, the whole thing makes a mockery of the integrity of the competition, giving us a points deduction with just 9 games to go.

I think it’s irrelevant that the season is over. One thing for sure it’s not getting increased at all. It’s about making them uncomfortable and taking this unjust system all the way, even if it does nothing to change the verdict.

If we’re down and they increase the penalty, which they won’t, it doesn’t matter anyway, still down

 

[TMFwanstead]

Because then you end the season not knowing if they are going to increase it a few days later and relegate you.

When you appeal it can go up as well as down.

If we get relegated there is absolutely zero chance of them changing it and relegating someone else.

Even now, the whole thing makes a mockery of the integrity of the competition, giving us a points deduction with just 9 games to go.

My understanding Pope is the appeal IC cannot increase the penalty

 

[Pope John XXIII]

My understanding Pope is the appeal IC cannot increase the penalty

Is that confirmed?

Generally appeals in my experience can go either way?

When I appeal an exam grade I have to let the student know it can go down as well

Is it actually stated anywhere it can't go up?

If so then agreed, we should appeal anything and have made it clear we would

 

[TMFwanstead]

Is that confirmed?

Generally appeals in my experience can go either way?

When I appeal an exam grade I have to let the student know it can go down as well

Is it actually stated anywhere it can't go up?

If so then agreed, we should appeal anything and have made it clear we would

When following the Everton appeal process their YouTube channel had an ‘expert’ on who said the panel could not increase the original penalty

 

[TMFwanstead]

Forest will make a determination on whether to appeal based upon what they get and what the judgement says. Irrespective of what we want such as an appeal to any points I believe 3 or less will be accepted to avoid further distraction

 

[Thewolf/jimmygordon]

Mao has promised more than once on here there will be no points deduction

So he's the next one to start blaming for stuff on here if we do get any

 

[Barry Goldie]

Mao has promised more than once on here there will be no points deduction

So he's the next one to start blaming for stuff on here if we do get any

Damn you Mao, if we get a deduction, Damn you I say. The buck stops with you

 

[paz1967]

Our best result this season? 4 points eh

 

[finbar70]

Is that confirmed?

Generally appeals in my experience can go either way?

When I appeal an exam grade I have to let the student know it can go down as well

Is it actually stated anywhere it can't go up?

If so then agreed, we should appeal anything and have made it clear we wou