Apologies for taking this sentence by sentence to an extent
I actually think your post unintentionally explains exactly why the stand names make sense.
You keep framing it as “sentimental memories” of older fans, but the club isn’t honouring that era because a particular generation enjoyed it more. It’s honouring it because that group achieved something so extraordinary that it fundamentally eclipses everything else in Forest’s history.
I disagree that this is why they have done it
I think they are catering to your generation of fans again.
Robertson has died and the club know it will go down well with a significant section. They also have the experience with Taylor and his family and the campaign to name a stand after him.
I don't disagree about the scale of how extraordinary it was, but I think as much as anything this is seen as an open goal for the club in fan relations
Maybe that's a good thing, but the popular thing isn't always the right thing.
You mention Billy Walker, Pearce, the 1959 side etc — all absolutely worthy figures in our history. But none of them transformed the global stature of the club in the way Clough, Taylor and Robertson did. That isn’t disrespectful, it’s just reality.
And that era has been comprehensively and completely honoured. It's in everything. 3 stands out of four now.
But our club is over 160 years old. All our focus is on 4 years of it. The same manager was actually more successful than we have ever been at any other time 10 years later, but we don't even celebrate that.
Stop and reflect a minute. An FA Cup in 1959 was about the height of what it was possible to win.
We already have a fan on here completely dismissing 157 years of our history because only those four years matter.
Are you sure you don't give a shit about McKinley, Walker and co more because you werent there?
And the irony is you say “nothing else will ever matter as much” as though that’s somehow unfair. But football clubs don’t artificially flatten their history to make every era feel equally important. Some achievements are bigger than others. That’s true at every club.
Yes, they are
But that is where you have some balance.
We don't define the entire 20th century by WWII; we acknowledge the key role it played in the century but we don't study that 6 years to the exclusion of the other 94- or maybe some people do?
Yet at Forest, this is more or less exactly what we do. We don't have any balance, even for the wider and longer term achievements or the manager from that same era.
My example, Stuart Pearce, was a player of that same Clough era - just the bit we never talk about. He won 4 trophies and was robbed of a 5th- very close to what Robertson won- and because of Liverpool he only had the chance to play for us in Europe in his penultimate season.
People forget that there are some absolutely brilliant players in that later era who were robbed of the chance to repeat some of those European feats.
When we see the pre game video, how much of it is from the 77-80 era, how much of it is in black and white, and how much of it is from 87-91? This video is typical of what I am talking about
90% of it is from that same era
A couple of goals in black and white, at least one from Storey-Moore. 2 goals by Pearce. A spattering of other 80s goals. 2 I think by Collymore, one by Earnshaw.
Fans from the 70s, fans from the 70s, fans from the 2020s, fans from the 70s.
It's a perfectly fine video - but it just shows the scale of the bias I am talking about. We won 2 cups in the late 80s- nothing
Real Madrid don’t apologise for constantly centring the Di Stéfano era.
Because they don't. It's one part of their history and treated as such
Liverpool don’t avoid celebrating Paisley and Shankly in case younger fans feel excluded.
That's a really disingenuous statement
Firstly, NO ONE has said we should avoid celebrating 77-80
Liverpool celebrate a very wide variety of eras, including ones their current younger fans will remember
And no one has said anything about "younger fans feeling excluded". That just comes across as an older guy parroting Daily Mail headlines having a go at younger people they know nothing about for "participation awards" and "hurt feelings".
Manchester United’s identity is overwhelmingly shaped by Busby and Ferguson.
Two successful eras, the latter of which most fans will remember and have been there for.
The reason Forest’s stand names gravitate toward 77–80 is because that period wasn’t just “a good team” — it was the defining achievement of the club itself.
I think this is the fundamental difference between myself and many of the people here
You say that you don't believe that those 4 years alone matter.
Yet here you are saying exactly that.
161 years of history but just four of them, which you happened to be there for, matter
I agree they matter, a great deal. But I also think that this club has done a lot of worthy things in it's history before, since and probably will again
You say it's the defining moment.
Do you, in your life, have just one defining moment? Just one week or month or year that really matters or gives it meaning? I hope not!
And honestly, I think you slightly undermine your own argument with the Panthers example. You’re basically admitting there’s a difference between personally sentimental memories and objectively historic achievements. You felt more emotionally connected to the recent win because you were there — but that doesn’t make it more important historically.
I am not weighing up "historical importance"
I am saying that a club belongs to it's fans- all of them.
I will never see Forest in a more weighty or important moment than you have. That's a fact.
But the club is mine as much as it is yours, and it is an 18 year olds as much as mine. It is there to entertain us all, to connect us to our local area, and to other local people.
That's why all our personal histories have importance. Not
more importance or the
same importance. But more than "3% of the pre match video" importance
I have spent my whole Forest supporting life paying homage to the late 70s, a bit of homage to the 90s and other eras would be nice
www.wsc.co.uk
