Had similar when I had my over 40 medical check. She looked at me, my body fat (I was in good shape, actually, might have been around the Men's Health thing, thinking about it, it must have been) and weight and said she could clearly see there was no point looking at her charts or the BMI and then went on to wax lyrical about my stats, the right fats, blood pressure, another other such markers. But if you had taken the standard line, I'd have been overweight, maybe edging up to the upper reach of that.