It’s a strange situation to see Southgate go, because while he has obviously been very successful, and though there’s a significant chance the next manager will do worse than him, it feels like exactly the right time for him to depart and hopefully find someone who can work on taking us that one extra step - a step that I feel would always have eluded Southgate who, despite being a nice bloke with all the right intentions, never really built more than a functional side that ground its way to the business-end of tournaments. England felt like a team very much in his image; inexpressive, safe, serviceable, determined but not dynamic.
It’s a question really of whether you would have wanted to stick or twist - stick with the safety of solid results and nearly moments, or twist in the hope of finding somebody who can unlock the attacking talent that seemed to spend most of the tournament in the gaol of its own half, struggling to emerge from the rigidity of our defensive structure. Maybe Southgate would have eventually won a tournament, but there was always a feeling that any top team was beyond us in a knockout game. It’s a problem really that England have struggled to overcome for a generation - how to beat truly world-class nations when everything is on the line. It’s not unique to Southgate that that final obstacle remains.