I used to love watching Wildschut, but would I want him back, well the jury is out on that one. The way we play at present is as a team and I don't see Yanic as a team player. He was great to see going forward but his final ball was lacking and he was often greedy, we need our wingers to get the ball into the box and to find team mates and no matter how exciting he is he very rarely did this.
McManaman had the talent and the speed to use it but I wonder about his mental state given his last couple of seasons. Can he pick himself up after his fall from grace and get back to being the player he was, somehow I doubt it.
For me then both of them would be a risk to bring home. Is the risk worth taking? Only Paul Cook can answer that.