Hard to judge. It's a frustrating article as.it doesn't seem to indicate the metrics they've used to freeze accounts.
"At Manchester United, for example, fans can have their season ticket revoked if they do not attend or forward their ticket to approved friends and family members for at least 16 out of 19 Premier League fixtures."
If this is the reason, then I don't see any problems with the decision. But are there really thousands of United season ticket holders doing that?
Their season ticket usage rules haven't changed in some time and seem entirely fair to me:
"We can confirm that our seat usage policy will remain unchanged for the 2026/27 season. This means Season Ticket holders will therefore continue to need to attend the match, forward, list for resale or donate the cost of their seat through our official channels for at least 16 out of 19 Premier League matches.
This decision follows constructive discussions with fan representatives on the Fans’ Advisory Board and wider supporter groups. We understand the challenges supporters face – particularly with our matches’ dates and timings being rearranged after selection for broadcast – and we recognise the importance of a policy that is both fair and flexible.
We are encouraged that the vast majority of Season Ticket holders are on course to meet their usage threshold this season, and Old Trafford and the team continue to benefit from a strong attendance and a vibrant atmosphere with very few empty seats.
We thank our Season Ticket holders for their loyal support.
We know our Season Ticket holders value the flexibility and choice we provide through our resale and forwarding options and we will continue to offer these with no increase to current charges for supporters. As a reminder, fans are not charged unless a ticket is listed for resale within two weeks of the fixture.
We are proud to retain the option of donating the cost of tickets to the foundation.
Since this was introduced, £2million has been raised for our Foundation, helping young people in our local community feel safe, happy and empowered to fulfil their ambitions. We thank our fans for their generous donations.
Ticketing is a topic fans are passionate about, and we understand the call for more transparency on ballots and allocations. Following discussions with our Fans’ Advisory Board and Fans’ Forum, we will reintroduce the publication of ticketing data on the club website from next season. We will work with the Fans’ Forum and Ticketing Sub-Group to agree specific details and the timing of publication.
We understand that European ticket collections are important to the integrity of the credit system, and we have agreed to reintroduce collections for as many European away games as possible from next season, should we qualify. We will work with our Fans’ Advisory Board and Fans’ Forum to review the collection operation to ensure it is as efficient as possible for travelling fans.
We can confirm that all our current concessions for general admission season tickets will remain in place. This means that the following will be the lowest concessionary prices in each category next season:
Under 16s = £12 (family area)
16-17-year-olds = £17
18-20-year-olds = £25.50
Over 66-year-olds = £25.50