DID men land on the moon?

Welshtel

Vital Football Hero
I watched a Channel 5 programme ('think it was Ch 5 anyway) recently, which I've seen before years ago or a similar documentary, that shot down a lot of ideas that man DID actually go to the moon. It was quite convincing, saying that there was no dust plume when they took off from the moon's surface, they showed 'photo's taken on the moon' which had accuracy markers for measurement etc, which were obviously added afterwards. There were the usual allegations that it was all staged in a big studio in area 51. They said that a human being could not stand the radiation in space etc, that the spacecraft was not sufficiently protected from the radiation etc etc. And many more convincing arguments.

SO what's the opinion on all these things? Can the cited 'fraud' be substantiated or refuted? And what does it really mean if it IS found to be a hoax and the US didn't send men to the moon? If the Chinese now send someone up there (as I think it is being reported that they are going to soon) and it is found that it never happened, what will be the world outcome?

The Russian Soyuz craft had a monkey in it, if I remember, so those monkeys survived the radiation for a start (as far as we know). And IF it never took place, wouldn't Russian Scientists for example have quickly denied the possibility of a moon landing in the press and kicked up stink? They would SURELY have wanted to make the USA look like idiots.

An international hoax and claims that it was all made up will surely make the USA look really stupid. How will governments react if was proven that man NEVER went to the moon?

For me, it would be SO embarrassing to watch a retraction from the US Space agency, I would be glued to the TV when the explanation was given. And what of all those little pieces of moon rock that we saw in US Museums? And the resultant 'research' that was produced from the trip, the study of the rocks and possible space bacteria etc. - how will all that be dealt with?

 
The best bit of evidence you need is Armstrong trying to land the machine pod on earth in a training exercise. He couldn't do it. He couldn't control the pod. He had to jump out before the machine hit the earth. Smashed into a million pieces.

Doing the same scenario in space would have been 100 times harder. It never happened. Biggest hoax of all time.

May have happened in recent times but didn't back in the 70's.

As for the radiation, of course there is radiation in space, but the further you go out the worse it gets.

The moon is around 250000 miles away.
 
Real Deal - 8/5/2014 19:41

The best bit of evidence you need is Armstrong trying to land the machine pod on earth in a training exercise. He couldn't do it. He couldn't control the pod. He had to jump out before the machine hit the earth. Smashed into a million pieces.

Doing the same scenario in space would have been 100 times harder. It never happened. Biggest hoax of all time.

May have happened in recent times but didn't back in the 70's.

As for the radiation, of course there is radiation in space, but the further you go out the worse it gets.

The moon is around 250000 miles away.

You're so wrong, RD. The low gravity on the Moon makes it easier to land in space than on Earth.

There is so much irrefutable evidence that shows them landing that it is not in doubt. From amateur radio enthusiast receiving signals that could only come from the Moon, to photographs of the tyre marks left by the Rover. It's all there, if you want to look.
 
SEE? That's what I have trouble with. One argument seems irrefutable but another seems to make light of it. The most difficult thing for me is the Russian scientists accepted it and never tried to make claims that it couldn't have happened.
 
That's just it Welshtel, they would have surely published any evidence to the contrary.

Every bit of "evidence" highlighted by the conspiracy theorists can be explained. They never seem to get around to explaining the evidence that it happened.

The mirror placed on the Moon alone shows we were there.
 
The 10 key claims made by the conspiracy theorists, debunked:

1) When the astronauts are putting up the American flag it waves. There is no wind on the Moon.

The flag is held up by a horizontal bar and simply moves when it is unfurled and as the pole is being fixed into position by the astronauts. The flagpole is light, flexible aluminium and continues to vibrate after the astronauts let go, giving the impression of blowing in the wind.

2) No stars are visible in the pictures taken by the Apollo astronauts from the surface of the Moon.

The Apollo landing takes place during lunar mornings, with the Sun shining brightly. The stars are not bright enough in this light to be captured in the photographs.

3) No blast crater is visible in the pictures taken of the lunar landing module.

The landing module touches down on solid rock, covered in a layer of fine lunar dust, so there is no reason why it would create a blast crater. Even if the ground were less solid, the amount of thrust being produced by the engines at the point of landing and take off is very low in comparison to a landing on Earth because of the relative lack of gravitational pull.

4) The landing module weighs 17 tons and yet sits on top of the sand making no impression. Next to it astronauts’ footprints can be seen in the sand.

The layer of lunar dust is fairly thin, so the landing module sits on the solid rock. The dust, whilst blown away by the blast from the descent engines, quickly settles back on the ground and is under the astronauts when they begin their moonwalk.

5) The footprints in the fine lunar dust, with no moisture or atmosphere or strong gravity, are unexpectedly well preserved, as if made in wet sand.

The lack of wind on the moon means the footprints in fine, dry lunar dust aren’t blown away in the way they would be if made in a similar substance on Earth.

6) When the landing module takes off from the Moon’s surface there is no visible flame from the rocket.

The rockets in the landing module are powered by fuel containing a combination of hydrazine and dinitrogen tetroxide, which burn with no visible flame.

7) If you speed up the film of the astronauts walking on the Moon’s surface they look like they were filmed on Earth and slowed down.

The best you can say is: yes, a bit, but not really.

8) The astronauts could not have survived the trip because of exposure to radiation from the Van Allen radiation belt.

This claim is largely based on a claim from a Russian cosmonaut. The short time it takes to pass through the belt, combined with the protection from the spacecraft, means any exposure to radiation would be very low.

9) The rocks brought back from the Moon are identical to rocks collected by scientific expeditions to Antarctica.

Some Moon rocks have been found on Earth, but they are all scorched and oxidised from their entry into the Earth’s atmosphere as asteroids. Geologists have confirmed with complete certainty that the Apollo rocks must have been brought from the Moon by man.

10) All six Moon landings happened during the Nixon administration. No other national leader has claimed to have landed astronauts on the Moon, despite 40 years of rapid technological development.

This is a favourite among conspiracy theorists because it needs no evidence but points the finger at the presidency of Richard Nixon. The fact is that after the Apollo landings, the race had been won and the money dried up. The USSR has no interest in coming second, and politicians on both side realised that lower-orbit missions had much greater commercial and military potential.
 
Its one of the good conspiracy theories though Ex. As someone who wasn't alive when it happens, i've grown up with more of the conspiracy argument than the argument it actually happened. One argument that always stuck with me was from a documentary I saw in my teens where a former NASA employee stated that although they had the technology to land there, they never had anything near advanced enough to land a man.

To me it seems fairly baffling if true. As Heath says (and again, from the viewpoint of a younger person) we're fed a lot of the conspiracy documentary's but never any programmes about how it DID happen.

It probably did happen, but they do nothing to convince those who question it do they?
 
Well if it was a hoax - it was one of the best hoaxes and so many people were in it and they all kept quiet about it... AMAZING! Nah it did happen and so much knowledge has been built on it - no hoax folks !!!
 
HeathfieldRoad1874 - 8/5/2014 19:54

Real Deal - 8/5/2014 19:41

The best bit of evidence you need is Armstrong trying to land the machine pod on earth in a training exercise. He couldn't do it. He couldn't control the pod. He had to jump out before the machine hit the earth. Smashed into a million pieces.

Doing the same scenario in space would have been 100 times harder. It never happened. Biggest hoax of all time.

May have happened in recent times but didn't back in the 70's.

As for the radiation, of course there is radiation in space, but the further you go out the worse it gets.

The moon is around 250000 miles away.

You're so wrong, RD. The low gravity on the Moon makes it easier to land in space than on Earth.

There is so much irrefutable evidence that shows them landing that it is not in doubt. From amateur radio enthusiast receiving signals that could only come from the Moon, to photographs of the tyre marks left by the Rover. It's all there, if you want to look.

LOL Heath I am stunned that so many people have effectively fallen for the plot of a film Capricorn one. Do you know that before Peter Hyams who wrote the screen play in 1977( He also covered the broadcasts of the Apollo missions for CBS) got his film made no one had proposed this hypothesis. Including the Russians who had the most to gain from it. The simple lack of understanding of the science involved(you rightly point out the zero gravity issue regards the lander) says it all.
 
Next thing we'll hear that september 11th and 7th July were a hoax!!!
 
LOL

Sure, let's go for the laugh.

Deus created the World in 7 days. Man must be able to wipe his ass on a globe, just a spec off the usual terrain.

[youtube=9475NpYv1M0]
 
If this was a one off achievement I could understand the doubters, but there several moon missions involving thousands of people.

How on earth, or moon, would they have been able to cover it up time after time. It makes no sense whatsoever.

I can believe that photos may have been enhanced afterwards and at a stretch, possibly re-inacted if the originals were so poor, but to suggest it didnt happen is pure lunacy, sorry for another pun!
 
EX all the points you have said is just the same as the people who have doubts. They are not facts they are just theories that have been fed by nasa and you believe it. Bottom line is we don't know if it happened as none of us have landed on the moon.

So your just being as ignorant and stupid as the the conspiracy nutters.
 
Real Deal - 9/5/2014 09:38

EX all the points you have said is just the same as the people who have doubts. They are not facts they are just theories that have been fed by nasa and you believe it. Bottom line is we don't know if it happened as none of us have landed on the moon.

So your just being as ignorant and stupid as the the conspiracy nutters.

Sorry RD I'm not, that was just a snapshot of the overwhelming evidence that we landed on the moon. There is volumes and volumes of it. I was part of the CERN initiative that led to the global HPC network across universities all over the world - the data that for nigh on 20 years after the moon landings was still being used for research.

If you think you can fool tens of thousands upon tens thousands of the Worlds greatest academics, along with thousands of the Worlds best research institutions, then you simply don't know your subject.

Did you know that as recently as 2012 the Chinese satellite that they sent up to map the moon took such detailed pictures of the moon that they could see/view ALL the evidence of the moon landings?

Sorry RD, don't get sucked in by the conspiracy nutters, it's complete and utter nonsense fed by the Americans usual paranoia about anything that any Government ever does.

It's pretty sad really, it really is.
 
HeathfieldRoad1874 - 9/5/2014 09:52

LOL. Less gravity means the harder the fall. British education in Science really is bad, isn't it!!!!!

I need say no more.

And don't forget they could jump twice as high because they were using bungee ropes.

I really do find this whole nonsense sad; if the deniers can't even grasp the basic law of physics, the laws of motion and mass or the rigours of empirical evidence, what can anyone say or do to convince them that their views are simply the result of fantasy?

It's no wonder some of those astronauts punched these people.
 
As supporters, we have had to refute so called evidence of a hoax, but not once have I seen a conspiracy theorist explain away the irrefutable evidence of the landings actually taking place. It's almost like they are scared to, because it blows their theories out of the water.

It wouldn't make great TV, I suppose. Conspiracy theory shows attract more viewers.
 
HeathfieldRoad1874 - 9/5/2014 10:12

As supporters, have had to refute so called evidence of a hoax, but not once have I seen a conspiracy theorist explain away the irrefutable evidence of the landings actually taking place. It's almost like they are scared to, because it blows their theories out of the water.

It wouldn't make great TV, I suppose. Conspiracy theory shows attract more viewers.

But what does that really say about us and our education system now, what does it say about our lack of teaching or understanding of critical thinking?

It really saddens me that we've sunk to such depths, why are people so gullible and so easy to exploit now?

It just doesn't make any sense to me, both here and in the states there must be some fundamental flaws in our education system(s), and not least in how TV programs like this affects viewers psychologically.

I get why TV producers make it, the masses seem to lap this stuff up now, I just can't get my head around why?!

 
We've had this discussion on VV several times. The 9/11 conspiracy theory being a particularly difficult one to deal with.

I think it's great to be sceptical - it's what leads us to great discoveries in many ways - but at some point you have to take a view on the evidence available and admit it's time to stop being silly about it. It seems that some like to go beyond this point, and nothing can stop them, and that is truly worrying.

In short, human nature leads us to question, so it's not necessarily all bad, but education does need to play a part in controlling it to be used effectively.